Jastrow, Robert;
The Enchanted Loom: Mind in the Universe
Simon and Schuster, 1983, 183 pages
ISBN 0671433083, 9780671433086
topics: | brain | neuro-science | evolution | psychology | illusion
The story is extensively simplified and downright incorrect in places, but the telling, and the excellent b&w illustrations, spin a vivid tale. Jastrow was a geophysicist who foounded NASA's Goddard Institute. 1. Across the Threshold of Life 2. The Beginnings of Intelligence 3. Thinking in the Dark: The Smell Brain 4. Into the Light: The Vision Brain 5. Brains and Computers 6. Circuits in the Brain 7. A Guiding Hand 8. The Final Step 9. The Old Brain and the New 10. Our Brain's Successor 11. The Thinking Computer 12. An End and a Beginning
[3,4 billion years ago - Life appears] Nature's experiments on the origin of life seem to have come to fruition in a rather short time. This fact suggests that the experiments may have been easy, and the chances of success fairly high. According to the fossile record, relatively complicated organisms like bacteria already existed when the earth was only one billion years old. Although a bacterium seems like a simple kind of life to us, it is a quite complex chemical factory, whose existence depends on the simultaneous manufacture of several thousand different kinds of chemicals. Bacteria are far more advanced than those simple creatures that first wriggled across the threshold of life on the earth. If bacteria already existed when the earth was one billion years old, a long period of evolution must have preceded their appearance, in which the chemical machinery that makes up the business of life for a bacterium was slowly being worked out and improved.. This implies that the threshold of life itself must have been crossed far earlier - perhaps when the earth was only a few hundred million years old, or even younger. A few hundred million years is not a long time for such an important experiment; if the experiment succeeded as quickly as that, the probability of its success must have been fairly high.. In the next half billion years or so, very little happeed; at least, little that is preserved in the fossil record. p.22-23
The first fishes possesed a first-class skeleton with bones in fin as well as spine. They also posessed a brain. It was a very small brain, but it was the first one that had existed on the earth up to that time. p.24 [300 million years ago - the first Reptiles] The fish's brains is divided cleanly into three compartments: a front compartment for smell, a middle compartment for vision, and a rear compartment for balance and coordination. p.24 [ reptile forebears were similar. fig. 128] These arrangements were inherited from the simple brain of the fishes. The receptors for vision and smell were coordinated in a region between the smell brain and vision brain, which was a command post called the diencephalon. Here, the inputs from different senses were compared and put together for a program of action. p. 128 The basic instincts of survival - sexual desire, the search for food and the aggression responses of "fight-or-flight" - were wired into this region of the reptile's brain. 129
When the mammals evolved out of the reptiles, their brains began to change. First they developed a new package of instincts, related to the reptilian instincts for sex and procreation, but modified for the special needs of a mammalian lifestyle. Chief among these was the instincts for parental care of the young. Here was a revolutionary advance over the behavior of reptile parents, for whom the newly hatched young provided a tasty snack if they could catch them. But the reptile young were prepared to fight for their lives. In the population of the mammals, on the other hand, the young arrived in a helpless and vulnerable state, and parental affection was essential for their survival. The new instincts of the mammals for parental care did not replace the older reptilian instincts; they augmented them. The ancient programs of the reptile brain - the search for food, the pursuit of a mate, and flight from the predator - were still essential to survival. As a result, the command post in the brain that controlled instintive behavior grew larger. The brains of the mammals changed in another important way, that was related to their nocturnal lifestyle. As these animals passed into their 100-million-year time of darkness, the vision brain diminished in importance and the smell brain expanded. The two swellings in the smell brain were the cerebral hemispheres. In the beginning, when the smell was the main function of the cerebral hemispheres, these parts of the brain were modest in size and could be fitted into the cranium of the mammal without wrinkling or folding. Later, when the ruling reptiles disappeared and the mammals began to move about by day and rely on the sense of vision as well as smell, more circuits had to be added to the brain to receive the new information from the eyes and analyze it. The added circuits for vision were in the cerebral hemispheres, which swelled to an even larger size as a result.
The growth of the cerebral cortex accelerated further in man´s immediate ancestors, and reached explosive proportions in the last million years of human history, culminating in the appearance of Homo Sapiens. The primitive region in the brain, that held the circuits for the instinctive behavior of the reptile and the old mammal, was now completely enveloped by and buried within the human cerebral cortex. Yet this ancient command post, relic of our distant past, is still active within us; it still vies with the cerebral cortex for control of the body, pitting the inherited programs of the old brain against the flexible responses of the new one. Experiments suggest that parental feelings, source of some of the finest human emotion, still spring from these primitive, programmed areas of the brain that go back to the time of the old mammal, more than 100 million years ago. One part of the old brain, called the hypothalamus, is only the size of a walnut in the human brain, and yet a minute electrical stimulus applied to this region in the brain can create the emotional states of anger, anxiety or acute fear. The stimulation of nearby regions, only a few tenths of an inch away, produces sexual desire, or a craving for food or water. The hypothalamus also appears to contain centers for aggression, killing, and fight-or-flight responses. Experiments indicate that states of anger and aggression are created by electrical signals originating in the hypothalamus. The hypothalamus behaves as though it contains a gate that can open to let out a display of anger or bad temper. Normally, this gate is kept closed, but now and then the animal´s senses tell its brain that its rights are endangered; a mate is lured away, food is stolen, or threat signals are received; and then the package of brain survival programs called the "emotions" comes into play, and an electrical signal to open the gate comes from som ancient center of instinct deep within the brain. It is as if two mentalities resided in the same body. One mentality is ruled by emotional states that have evolved as a part of age-old programs for survival. The other mentality is ruled by reason, and resides in the cerebral cortex. In man, the cerebral cortex, or new brain, is usually master over the old brain. But the reptile and the old mammal still lie within us. These properties of the human brain lead to a prediction regarding the life that will follow man. As nature built the new brain on top of the old in our ancestors, so too, in the next stage of evolution after man, we can expect that a still newer and greater brain will join the "old" cerebral cortex, to work in concert with the cerebral cortex in directing the behavior of a form of life as superior to man as he is to the ancient forest mammal. The book has quite a few errors, and is rather opinionated. E.g. here's a challenge to the the E = mc² law (p. 81): Each computing cell combines the signals from several hundred separate cells in the retina and forms a small, circular patch of light out of them. The large number of photons being transformed, it is claimed, should result in all of us exploding. I am not sure where this comes from. - AM
to contribute some excerpts from your favourite book to
book
excerptise. send us a plain text file with
page-numbered extracts from your favourite book. You can preface your
extracts with a short review.
email to (bookexcerptise [at] gmail [dot] com).